News

Study: Mental Health Apps Are Loaded With Scientific Language, But Light On Scientific Evidence

Study: Mental Health Apps Are Loaded With Scientific Language, But Light On Scientific Evidence
Mental Health
uncaptioned image

Apps claiming to effectively diagnose and manage mental health disorders are multiplying and their audience is growing, but does the science really support their claims?

Findings from a new study in Nature Digital Medicine suggest that users should be cautious. Not only do few of the apps rely on real-world experience in their design, argues the study, most also lack any credible scientific evidence to support their claims.

Researchers identified 1,435 mental health apps from the two most popular app stores (iTunes and Google Play), and then focused on 73 of the apps “representing the most highly ranked” to evaluate their claims. The claims pertain to common mental health disorders, including depression, anxiety and substance abuse, and a few less common, notably schizophrenia. Nearly 65% of the apps claim to effectively diagnose conditions, improve symptoms or mood, or foster self-management.

The study found that “scientific language” was used by 44% of the apps to support their claims, although these claims included “techniques not validated by literature searches.”  In fact, only one app included a citation to published scientific literature. So while there is plenty of science speak in the apps’ descriptions, “high-quality evidence is not commonly described,” according to the study.

A minority of the apps (14%) included a description of “design or development involving lived experience,” suggesting that the majority did not include real-world experience as part of their development—or at minimum it wasn’t mentioned in their descriptions.

Other techniques used to promote the apps included “wisdom of the crowd” appeals (32% of the apps), in which reference is made to the collective wisdom of people choosing to use the app (i.e. anecdotal user reviews), rather than scientific evidence. 


Article Source:https://www.forbes.com/sites/daviddisalvo/2019/03/31/study-mental-health-apps-are-loaded-with-scientific-language-but-light-on-real-science/?ss=healthcare#504e7774e3cd

Apps claiming to effectively diagnose and manage mental health disorders are multiplying and their audience is growing, but does the science really support their claims?

Findings from a new study in Nature Digital Medicine suggest that users should be cautious. Not only do few of the apps rely on real-world experience in their design, argues the study, most also lack any credible scientific evidence to support their claims.

Researchers identified 1,435 mental health apps from the two most popular app stores (iTunes and Google Play), and then focused on 73 of the apps “representing the most highly ranked” to evaluate their claims. The claims pertain to common mental health disorders, including depression, anxiety and substance abuse, and a few less common, notably schizophrenia. Nearly 65% of the apps claim to effectively diagnose conditions, improve symptoms or mood, or foster self-management.

The study found that “scientific language” was used by 44% of the apps to support their claims, although these claims included “techniques not validated by literature searches.”  In fact, only one app included a citation to published scientific literature. So while there is plenty of science speak in the apps’ descriptions, “high-quality evidence is not commonly described,” according to the study.

A minority of the apps (14%) included a description of “design or development involving lived experience,” suggesting that the majority did not include real-world experience as part of their development—or at minimum it wasn’t mentioned in their descriptions.

Other techniques used to promote the apps included “wisdom of the crowd” appeals (32% of the apps), in which reference is made to the collective wisdom of people choosing to use the app (i.e. anecdotal user reviews), rather than scientific evidence. 


Article Source:https://www.forbes.com/sites/daviddisalvo/2019/03/31/study-mental-health-apps-are-loaded-with-scientific-language-but-light-on-real-science/?ss=healthcare#504e7774e3cd

NEWS​

Related News

Singapore – Singapore Health Technologies Ecosystem is ECHAlliance Ecosystem of the Month – June

12 Jun 2024
This month we are featuring our Singapore - Singapore Health Technologies Ecosystem as our Ecosystem of the Month.

Continence Thematic Innovation Ecosystem

11 Jun 2024
In celebration of Continence Week, we are excited to announce a collaborative webinar with the WFIPP focusing on our Continence Thematic Innovation Ec...

Presenting Kuopio Health members: ThingLink Oy

10 Jun 2024
ThingLink Oy is a Finnish learning technology company with global operations that develops user-friendly, scalable tools for creating interactive and ...

Presenting Kuopio Health members: Smart Visionary Solutions Oy

10 Jun 2024
Smart Visionary Solutions brings digital solutions to learning.

Presenting Kuopio Health members: Novo Granules Oy

10 Jun 2024
Novo Granules provides new pharmaceutical manufacturing solutions. Novo Granules is a company focused on dry granulation. The company is registered in...

Kuopio Health ecosystem R&D actors in spotlight – UEF SIB Labs

10 Jun 2024
UEF SIB Labs Science – Innovation – Business operates as a part of the Department of Technical Physics at the Faculty of Science, Forestry and Technol...

Become a member

Join ECHAlliance to amplify your organisation’s message, grow your networks, connect with innovators and collaborate globally.
 
First name *
Last Name *
Email Address *
Country *
Position *
First name *
Last Name *
Email Address *
Country *
Position *